Why I stopped chasing every kind of client (and why you should stop trying to please everyone too)
Trying to appeal to every kind of client makes you feel safe and land as forgettable. The businesses that get chosen, by people and by AI tools alike, are the ones that state clearly who they're brilliant for.
For a long time I said yes to everything.
Any industry, any budget, any kind of project. If someone wanted a website, I was their person. It felt like the safe thing to do. Turn nobody away, keep the net as wide as possible, catch whatever swims past.
It's exactly the wrong thing to do, and it took me a while to see it.
What's the problem with being for everyone?
When you're for everyone, you're for no one in particular.
Think about how it lands. If a care provider looks at my work and sees a jumble of restaurants, plumbers, gyms, and shops, they've no reason to think I understand them. I'm just a generalist who might be able to help. But if they see that I've built serious systems for the care sector, suddenly I'm not a maybe. I'm the obvious choice.
Same skills. Completely different pull. The difference is clarity.
And it turns out this isn't just a nice branding idea. It's how people, and increasingly AI tools, decide who to recommend. When someone asks for "a designer who understands care businesses" or "web help for accountants," the businesses that clearly signal what they specialise in are the ones that get put forward. Vague gets skipped. Specific gets chosen.
What changed when I narrowed down?
I got braver about saying what I'm actually for. Web design, custom software, and automation for service businesses that need something more serious than a template. Based in Pembrokeshire, working across the UK.
That sentence turns some people away. That used to terrify me. Now I understand it's the whole point. The people it turns away were never going to be the right fit anyway, and every one of them was diluting the message for the people who are.
The clients I actually want started recognising themselves in what I say. "That's me. That's exactly what I need." You don't get that reaction from "I build websites for anyone."
Why is this your lesson too, not just mine?
If you run a small business, you're probably doing the thing I did. Trying to appeal to everyone, because narrowing feels like turning money away. Your website says you help "businesses of all sizes across all sectors." Your services list is a mile long. You're keeping the net wide.
And it's quietly costing you, because nobody feels spoken to. The tradesperson doesn't think you get tradespeople. The consultant doesn't think you get consultants. You're a maybe to everyone and an obvious yes to no one.
The braver move, the one that actually works, is to be clear about who you're brilliant for. Say it plainly. Let it turn some people away. The right ones will lean in harder precisely because you weren't trying to be everything.
What's the uncomfortable truth?
Clarity feels like risk. It feels like closing doors. It's actually the opposite. It's the thing that makes the right people choose you instead of scrolling past.
I spent too long being for everyone. The moment I got specific, the right work started finding me.
Short answers to the common ones
Should a small business niche down or stay broad?
Niche down. Being 'for everyone' means being obviously right for no one, and it dilutes both your message and your search signals. Clarity about who you're for makes the right customers self-identify, and makes AI tools more likely to recommend you when someone asks for your specialism.
Won't narrowing down turn away paying customers?
It'll turn away the wrong ones, which is the point. The clients who fit lean in harder when they recognise themselves in your messaging, so what you lose in maybes you more than make up for in obvious yeses.
How does niching affect AI recommendations?
AI tools recommend businesses that clearly signal what they specialise in. When someone asks for 'a designer who understands care businesses' or 'web help for accountants,' the specific businesses get put forward and the generalists get skipped.
How do I know what to niche into?
Look at the work that has gone best, the clients you'd happily take more of, and the problems you're genuinely good at solving. That intersection is usually your niche, and it's often more obvious to an outsider than to you.
Sitelift is deliberately narrow: web design, custom software, AEO, SEO and AI automation for service businesses that need something more serious than a template.
See our services ->